Get creative! Enjoy it straight from the jar, spread it on toast, waffles, pancakes, or bagels, or use it as a dip for apples, pretzels, graham crackers, and more. The possibilities are endless!
Unlike many brands that simply sprinkle toppings on plain peanut butter, every flavor starts with its own unique flavored base. We carefully hand-stir all of the mix-ins throughout the jar and finish each one with extra toppings on top. (See product photos!)
Our signature texture is called Smunchy not quite smooth and not quite crunchy.
Our all-natural, white chocolate, milk chocolate, dark chocolate, and butterscotch bases have a texture similar to traditional peanut butter. Many of our dessert-inspired flavors are thicker and best enjoyed with a spoon, almost like edible cookie dough.
Yes! Our Peanut Butter Flight includes four 8 oz jars of our top-selling signature flavors. It's the perfect way to discover your favorites or share with family and friends.
Several of our flavors are gluten-free. However, our small-batch kitchen also processes gluten-containing ingredients. We ensure everything is clean and sanitized between all small-batches so no cross contamination happens.
Nutrition Facts can be found on each product page. Simply scroll through the product photos to view the nutrition label.
(But let's be honest... it probably won't last that long.)
That's completely normal!
We don't add preservatives or stabilizers, so natural peanut oil separation is expected. Simply stir before enjoying if needed. Some flavors naturally develop more oil than others depending on the ingredients and mix-ins.
Shipping, heat, and normal package handling can occasionally cause our carefully hand-placed toppings to settle into the peanut butter.
Don't worry nothing is missing! The flavor, quality, and safety of your peanut butter are not affected.
Nope! Our peanut butter is shelf-stable and best stored at room temperature. Refrigeration can affect the texture and overall quality.
Email yummy@mustbenuts.com as soon as possible.
If your order hasn't shipped, we'll do our best to update the address.
Because our peanut butter is handcrafted in small batches and is a perishable food product, we cannot accept returns or exchanges. All sales are final.
If there's a problem with your order, please email yummy@mustbenuts.com. We truly care about our customers and will always do our best to help.
Orders may be canceled or modified within 24 hours of purchase.
After 24 hours, production may have already begun, so we're unable to guarantee changes or cancellations.
Every jar is handcrafted in our small-batch kitchen in Bluffdale, Utah.
We also offer FREE local pickup in Bluffdale.
Every jar is made fresh after you order.
Our official shipping window is up to 2 weeks, but most orders ship within 3–5 business days. You'll receive tracking information as soon as your order ships.
Yes! We proudly ship to Canada.
Please note that duties, taxes, brokerage fees, and other import charges are not included in your shipping cost and are the responsibility of the recipient. These fees must be paid before your package can be delivered.
If a package is refused by customs or the recipient declines to pay the required import fees, the shipment may be abandoned or destroyed by the carrier. Because of this, we are unable to issue refunds or replacements for refused international orders.
By placing an international order, you acknowledge and agree to these terms.
Yes!
Because our peanut butter contains no added preservatives or stabilizers, natural peanut oil may separate during shipping. Occasionally, that oil can saturate the pressure-sensitive seal, which may cause:
As long as the lid was securely attached and the jar arrived unopened, your peanut butter is safe to enjoy. This is an occasional cosmetic issue with natural peanut butter and does not affect the quality or safety of the product.
If you have any concerns, email yummy@mustbenuts.com.
During warmer months (May–September), chocolate and other heat-sensitive ingredients may soften or melt during shipping. Hand-placed toppings may also settle or mix into the peanut butter, and natural oil separation may increase.
While the appearance of your peanut butter may change, it is still safe to enjoy and the quality and flavor are not affected. Simply store your jar at room temperature or in a cool place and give it a good stir if needed.
To help preserve your peanut butter, we recommend bringing your package inside as soon as possible after delivery.
While we package every order with care, we cannot control shipping temperatures or packages left outdoors after delivery.
Peanut butter is heavy, and we package with care to prevent damage. All orders over $70 ship free!
Once your package has been accepted by USPS or UPS, delivery is handled by the carrier.
If your package shows as delivered but cannot be located:
Most USPS Priority, USPS Ground Advantage, and UPS shipments include up to $100 of carrier insurance.
If you have questions, email yummy@mustbenuts.com.
Most USPS Priority, USPS Ground Advantage, and UPS shipments include up to $100 of carrier insurance for damage.
If your package arrives damaged:
Please do not throw away the packaging, as the carrier may require it during the claims process.
Oh no! While we work hard to ensure every order is packed correctly, mistakes can happen.
Please email yummy@mustbenuts.com with your order number and photos (if applicable), and we'll make it right as quickly as possible.
Thanks for subscribing!
This email has been registered!
Love this company… My peanut butter is delicious and I will definitely be ordering again!
I love it!! Can’t wait to try more of them.
This one was great. It was almost like a strawberry cobbler.
This stuff is insane! I bought a jar at the lodge in Zion earlier today. My 9 yr old is currently eating it by the spoonful - after I did the same. Obviously I’m already online planning my order. But seriously, this stuff is soooooo good!
I love it, the pb is really smooth, the rice crispies are still crunchy and not stale!
