Sidebar

Categories

Availability

Price

$
to
$

Products

Filter
  • 10
  • 15
  • 20
  • 25
  • 30
  • 50
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Sort

Sort by:

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
  • Beggin Buddy Butter - Must Be NutsBeggin Buddy Butter - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Beggin Buddy Butter

    🐶 Beggin’ Buddy Butter – A Tail-Wagging Treat! 🥜🥓 Treat your pup to Beggin’ Buddy Butter, our all-natural peanut butter made just for dogs! Crafted with no added salt, oils, or preservatives, this wholesome blend is hand-stirred with chunks of bacon strip dog treats...
    $6.99
    $6.99
  • Beggin' Buddy Butter and Canine CookIe Crunch combo pack - Must Be NutsBeggin' Buddy Butter and Canine CookIe Crunch combo pack - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Beggin' Buddy Butter and Canine CookIe Crunch combo pack

    Spoil your furry friend with our Dog-Friendly Peanut Butter Pack, crafted with love and only the best natural ingredients! 🥜✨ These special blends are made with no added salt, oils, or preservatives, ensuring a wholesome and tail-waggingly good treat for your pup. 🐾 Beggin’...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Bravo Brew ButterBravo Brew Butter
    Must Be Nuts

    Bravo Brew Butter

    Light roast vibes. Bold flavor energy.Velvety white chocolate peanut butter meets a bold espresso kick.Infused with real espresso from our collab with Operator Coffee Club, this small-batch peanut butter delivers a smooth, roasty base hand-stirred to perfection. Packed with crunchy bits of dark chocolate...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Brigham City Peach Paradise CobblerBrigham City Peach Paradise Cobbler
    Must Be Nuts

    Brigham City Peach Paradise Cobbler

    Brigham City Peach Paradise Cobbler is summer in a jar!We’ve taken our creamy butterscotch peanut butter and swirled it with locally sourced Brigham City freeze-dried peaches and golden graham cracker crunch for the ultimate cobbler-inspired treat. Every bite is sweet, nutty, and peach-perfect —...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Canine Cookie Crunch - Must Be NutsCanine Cookie Crunch - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Canine Cookie Crunch

    Give your pup a treat they’ll go crazy for with Canine Cookie Crunch! Made with all-natural peanut butter, this special blend contains no added salt, oils, or preservatives—just pure goodness. Hand-stirred with crunchy milk bone pieces, it’s the perfect combination of creamy and crunchy...
    $6.99
    $6.99
  • Churrolicious - Must Be NutsChurrolicious - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Churrolicious

    The peanut butter that brought grown men to tears. 😭This viral fan-favorite is a decadent swirl of our handcrafted, small-batch butterscotch peanut butter, hand stirred and packed with crunchy churro pieces and cinnamon sugar. It’s sweet, warm, and dessert-like every spoonful tastes like the first...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Cookies and Dream Nirvana - Must Be NutsCookies and Dream Nirvana - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Cookies and Dream Nirvana

    A cookie lover’s dream in a jar.This indulgent flavor blends smooth white chocolate peanut butter with generous chunks of real Oreo cookies for the ultimate sweet-and-creamy combo. Hand-stirred in small batches and packed with crunch in every bite it’s dessert-level decadence you can eat...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Creature CrunchCreature Crunch
    Must Be Nuts

    Creature Crunch

    Unleash your spooky side with Creature Crunch! This white chocolate peanut butter is packed with colorful Halloween sprinkles and loaded with chunks of Twix and Snickers. It’s a monster mash of sweet, salty, and nutty goodness perfect for candy lovers and peanut butter fans...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Crunchy Campfire Treat - Must Be NutsCrunchy Campfire Treat - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Crunchy Campfire Treat

    S’mores, but make it peanut butter. 🔥This indulgent flavor features creamy white chocolate peanut butter, hand-stirred with gluten-free rice crispy rice cereal and swirls of marshmallow fluff for that nostalgic, fireside flavor no flame required. Topped with extra marshmallow and crispy bits for texture...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Golden Turtle SwirlGolden Turtle Swirl
    Must Be Nuts

    Golden Turtle Swirl

    Indulge in pure decadence with Golden Turtle Swirl. This luscious white chocolate peanut butter is blended with gooey caramel, crunchy pecans, and chunks of chocolate turtle candies. Sweet, salty, nutty, and rich, it’s inspired by the classic turtle candy but made even better in...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Great Pumpk'n RollGreat Pumpk'n Roll
    Must Be Nuts

    Great Pumpk'n Roll

    Celebrate fall with The Great Pumpk’n Roll! This decadent butterscotch peanut butter is swirled with chunks of pumpkin spice roll, rich chocolate chips, and a sprinkle of cozy pumpkin pie spices. It’s like your favorite autumn dessert rolled into creamy, nutty perfection. Whether you...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Honey Harvest BlissHoney Harvest Bliss
    Must Be Nuts

    Honey Harvest Bliss

    Honey Harvest Bliss Peanut Butter is the fall flavor you didn’t know you needed. Even if candy corn isn’t your go-to, this small-batch spread will surprise you. We start with our signature Smunchy Butter, infuse it with locally sourced Utah raw honey, and swirl...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Peanut Butter Overload - Must Be NutsPeanut Butter Overload - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Peanut Butter Overload

    Everything you love about peanut butter amplified.This rich, creamy white chocolate peanut butter is hand-stirred in small batches and fully loaded with all your favorites: *Crunchy Reese’s Pieces for classic peanut buttery bursts*Creamy peanut butter cups for smooth, melty indulgence*Crushed Nutter Butters for that...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Puppy Chow (Not for dogs *wink*) - Must Be NutsPuppy Chow (Not for dogs *wink*) - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)

    A sweet-and-salty snack classic now in peanut butter form.This creamy milk chocolate peanut butter is hand-stirred with crunchy Chex cereal and Heath toffee bits, then finished with a dusting of powdered sugar and even more crispy mix-ins on top. It’s nostalgic, crave-worthy, and totally...
    $12.99
    $12.99
  • Smunchy Butter - Must Be NutsSmunchy Butter - Must Be Nuts
    Must Be Nuts

    Smunchy Butter

    The heart of every Must Be Nuts flavor starts right here.Our natural peanut butter is crafted with the perfect salt-to-peanut ratio and ground to a unique “smunchy” texture—not too smooth, not too crunchy, but just right. 🥜It’s creamy with just the right amount of...
    $6.99
    $6.99
  • Zero Dark NuttyZero Dark Nutty
    Must Be Nuts

    Zero Dark Nutty

    Bold. Rich. Mission-ready.This powerhouse flavor blends silky milk chocolate peanut butter with real espresso from our friends at Operator Coffee Club. Each batch is hand-stirred to perfection and packed with salted caramel milk chocolate biscotti chunks for a crunchy, decadent finish. Whether you're fueling...
    $12.99
    $12.99

Recently Viewed Products