Sidebar

Categories

Availability

Price

$
to
$

New Flavors Coming Soon!

Filter
  • 10
  • 15
  • 20
  • 25
  • 30
  • 50
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Sort

Sort by:

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
  • Four Leaf Clover CrunchFour Leaf Clover Crunch
    Must Be Nuts

    Four Leaf Clover Crunch

    Luck Has Nothing to Do With It 🍀This flavor is pure magic. Four Leaf Clover Crunch starts with a rich, creamy milk chocolate peanut butter, hand-stirred in small batches with chunks of fudge mint cookies and Andes mint pieces for the perfect balance of...
    $14.99
    $14.99
  • Hoppy Scotch – Butterscotch Peanut Butter with Mini Cadbury EggsHoppy Scotch – Butterscotch Peanut Butter with Mini Cadbury Eggs
    Must Be Nuts

    Hoppy Scotch – Butterscotch Peanut Butter with Mini Cadbury Eggs

    Your Favorite Easter Treat Is Back! 🐰🍫Hoppy Scotch is here to make your spring sweeter. Our rich, small-batch Butterscotch Peanut Butter is hand-stirred with crunchy, chocolatey Mini Cadbury Eggs for the ultimate sweet and salty combo you've been waiting all year for.Finished with a...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Magically Nut-LiciousMagically Nut-Licious
    Must Be Nuts

    Magically Nut-Licious

    A Little Luck. A Lot of Magic. 🌈🍀 Meet Magically Nut-Licious — the St. Patrick's Day treat your spoon has been waiting for. A dreamy white chocolate peanut butter, hand-stirred in small batches and packed with crunchy Lucky Charms cereal pieces for that nostalgic,...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Midnight Brownie Crunch Peanut ButterMidnight Brownie Crunch Peanut Butter
    Must Be Nuts

    Midnight Brownie Crunch Peanut Butter

    Dark Chocolate Dreams in Every Jar Meet your new late-night obsession. Midnight Brownie Crunch is a rich, dark chocolate peanut butter hand-stirred with real cosmic brownie chunks and Sixlets candy then topped with even more brownie chunks and Sixlets for an over-the-top finish you...
    $14.99
    $14.99
  • Puppy LovePuppy Love
    Must Be Nuts

    Puppy Love

    Fall Head Over Heels 🤍Meet Puppy Love — our sweetest creation yet. This dreamy jar starts with a rich white chocolate peanut butter base, then gets loaded with nostalgic Valentine’s Grandma Circus Cookies and finished with festive Valentine’s sprinkles for the ultimate dessert-in-a-jar experience.Playful,...
    $10.99
    $13.99
    $10.99
  • Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling FlavorsSignature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors
    Must Be Nuts

    Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors

    ✨ Signature Peanut Butter FlightExperience the flavors that made Must Be Nuts go viral. Each flight includes four 8-oz jars of our bestselling signature creations — all handcrafted in small batches, loaded just like our 16-oz jars, and topped with extra mix-ins for maximum...
    $32.99
    $32.99

Recently Viewed Products