Sidebar

Categories

Availability

Price

$
to
$

New Flavors Coming Soon!

Filter
  • 10
  • 15
  • 20
  • 25
  • 30
  • 50
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Sort

Sort by:

  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
  • Golden Turtle SwirlGolden Turtle Swirl
    Must Be Nuts

    Golden Turtle Swirl

    Indulge in pure decadence with Golden Turtle Swirl. This luscious white chocolate peanut butter is blended with gooey caramel, crunchy pecans, and chunks of chocolate turtle candies. Sweet, salty, nutty, and rich, it’s inspired by the classic turtle candy but made even better in...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Great Pumpk'n RollGreat Pumpk'n Roll
    Must Be Nuts

    Great Pumpk'n Roll

    Celebrate fall with The Great Pumpk’n Roll! This decadent butterscotch peanut butter is swirled with chunks of pumpkin spice roll, rich chocolate chips, and a sprinkle of cozy pumpkin pie spices. It’s like your favorite autumn dessert rolled into creamy, nutty perfection. Whether you...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Holiday Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Festive FlavorsHoliday Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Festive Flavors
    Must Be Nuts

    Holiday Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Festive Flavors

    🎁 Holiday Peanut Butter Flight Give the gift of PEANUT BUTTER OBSESSION this season!Each box includes four 8-oz jars of our hand-stirred, small-batch holiday flavors — the perfect gift for friends, family, coworkers, or yourself. What’s Inside the Holiday Flight: 🎅 Santa's Sugar Cookie...
    $32.99
    $32.99
  • Honey Harvest BlissHoney Harvest Bliss
    Must Be Nuts

    Honey Harvest Bliss

    Honey Harvest Bliss Peanut Butter is the fall flavor you didn’t know you needed. Even if candy corn isn’t your go-to, this small-batch spread will surprise you. We start with our signature Smunchy Butter, infuse it with locally sourced Utah raw honey, and swirl...
    $10.99
    $12.99
    $10.99
  • Not My Gumdrop ButtonsNot My Gumdrop Buttons
    Must Be Nuts

    Not My Gumdrop Buttons

    Cozy up with Not My Gumdrop Buttons, a rich butterscotch peanut butter loaded with gingerbread cookie bits and stroopwafel chunks for warm holiday flavor in every bite. Finished with a gingerbread man cookie, a touch of cream cheese frosting, and festive sugar crystals —...
    $14.99
    $14.99
  • Santa’s Sugar Cookie SurpriseSanta’s Sugar Cookie Surprise
    Must Be Nuts

    Santa’s Sugar Cookie Surprise

    Celebrate the season with Santa’s Sugar Cookie Surprise, our hand-stirred white chocolate peanut butter crafted for creamy holiday perfection. Each jar is packed with real crumbled Christmas sugar cookies and finished with festive holiday sprinkles for the ultimate cookie-lover’s treat. What Makes It Magical:...
    $13.99
    $13.99
  • Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling FlavorsSignature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors
    Must Be Nuts

    Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors

    ✨ Signature Peanut Butter Flight Experience the flavors that made Must Be Nuts go viral. Each flight includes four 8-oz jars of our bestselling signature creations — all handcrafted in small batches, loaded just like our 16-oz jars, and topped with extra mix-ins for...
    $32.99
    $32.99

Recently Viewed Products