Skip to content

Free U.S. Shipping $70+ • Please allow 5-7 business days for orders to ship

yummy@mustbenuts.com

Free Shipping Over $70*

Search the store

Trending Now

churro
butterscotch
oreo
smunchy

Popular Products

Churrolicious

Cinnamon sugar peanut butter loaded with crunchy churro pieces—like your favorite sweet treat in a jar.Sweet, cozy, and packed with churro flavor, this one brings the perfect mix of cinnamon sugar and crunch to every bite.What's Inside Peanut butter base Cinnamon sugar Crunchy churro...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies & cream peanut butter loaded with chocolate cookie chunks for that classic flavor in every bite.Sweet, creamy, and packed with cookie pieces, this jar delivers a nostalgic cookies & cream experience with a peanut butter twist.What's Inside White chocolate peanut butter Chocolate cookie...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

White Chocolate peanut butter loaded with marshmallow and crunchy cereal pieces—like a s'more without the campfire.This nostalgic favorite is packed with sweet and crunchy mix-ins for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.What's Inside White Chocolate peanut butter Marshmallow Crunchy cereal pieces Texture &...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Trending Now

churro
butterscotch
oreo
smunchy

Popular Products

Churrolicious

Cinnamon sugar peanut butter loaded with crunchy churro pieces—like your favorite sweet treat in a jar.Sweet, cozy, and packed with churro flavor, this one brings the perfect mix of cinnamon sugar and crunch to every bite.What's Inside Peanut butter base Cinnamon sugar Crunchy churro...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies & cream peanut butter loaded with chocolate cookie chunks for that classic flavor in every bite.Sweet, creamy, and packed with cookie pieces, this jar delivers a nostalgic cookies & cream experience with a peanut butter twist.What's Inside White chocolate peanut butter Chocolate cookie...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

White Chocolate peanut butter loaded with marshmallow and crunchy cereal pieces—like a s'more without the campfire.This nostalgic favorite is packed with sweet and crunchy mix-ins for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.What's Inside White Chocolate peanut butter Marshmallow Crunchy cereal pieces Texture &...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Signature Flavors

Signature Flavors

Go to Signature Flavors

Beehive Smunchy Butter

Bravo Brew Butter

Churrolicious

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Peanut Butter Overload

Puppy Chow

Zero Dark Nutty

Smunchy Butter

Signature Flavors

Beehive Smunchy Butter

$10.99

$10.99

Unit price

per

Shop Now
Seasonal Flavors

Seasonal Flavors

Go to Seasonal Flavors

Midnight Brownie Crunch Peanut Butter

Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors
About Us
Contact us
FAQ'S

Home Your cart

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Loading...

Must Be Nuts

Peanut Butter that's meant to be enjoyed by the spoonful, without counting calories. Must Be Nuts offers a large variety of hand-made, flavored Peanut Butter you can eat like dessert!

Utah Made

yummy@mustbenuts.com

Shop By

Signature Flavors
Seasonal Flavors
About Us
Contact us
FAQ'S

Information

Frequently Asked Questions

Customer Service

Contact us

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign-up to get updates about new flavor drops, discounts, and more.

Your email

Follow Us

Facebook
Instagram

Marketing by Impact Marketing Solutions

Payment methods

Home
Search
Account
Cart
0 items

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose Options

Edit Option

Let me know when my PB is back!

Leave your email and we will notify as soon as the product / variant is back in stock

this is just a warning

Login

Email Address *

Password *

Forgot your password? Create account

Close

Search

Search

Trending Now

churro
butterscotch
oreo
smunchy

Popular Products

Churrolicious

Cinnamon sugar peanut butter loaded with crunchy churro pieces—like your favorite sweet treat in a jar.Sweet, cozy, and packed with churro flavor, this one brings the perfect mix of cinnamon sugar and crunch to every bite.What's Inside Peanut butter base Cinnamon sugar Crunchy churro...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies & cream peanut butter loaded with chocolate cookie chunks for that classic flavor in every bite.Sweet, creamy, and packed with cookie pieces, this jar delivers a nostalgic cookies & cream experience with a peanut butter twist.What's Inside White chocolate peanut butter Chocolate cookie...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

White Chocolate peanut butter loaded with marshmallow and crunchy cereal pieces—like a s'more without the campfire.This nostalgic favorite is packed with sweet and crunchy mix-ins for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.What's Inside White Chocolate peanut butter Marshmallow Crunchy cereal pieces Texture &...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Trending Now

churro
butterscotch
oreo
smunchy

Popular Products

Churrolicious

Cinnamon sugar peanut butter loaded with crunchy churro pieces—like your favorite sweet treat in a jar.Sweet, cozy, and packed with churro flavor, this one brings the perfect mix of cinnamon sugar and crunch to every bite.What's Inside Peanut butter base Cinnamon sugar Crunchy churro...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Cookies & cream peanut butter loaded with chocolate cookie chunks for that classic flavor in every bite.Sweet, creamy, and packed with cookie pieces, this jar delivers a nostalgic cookies & cream experience with a peanut butter twist.What's Inside White chocolate peanut butter Chocolate cookie...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Crunchy Campfire Treat

White Chocolate peanut butter loaded with marshmallow and crunchy cereal pieces—like a s'more without the campfire.This nostalgic favorite is packed with sweet and crunchy mix-ins for the perfect balance of flavor and texture.What's Inside White Chocolate peanut butter Marshmallow Crunchy cereal pieces Texture &...

$13.99; $13.99
Unit price: per

Menu

Sign In Create an Account

Richard Smith

Peanut buttery Heavenly

Peanut buttery Heavenly delicious!!

Peanut Butter Overload

Richard Smith

This is the best PB on the website

This is the best PB on the website. Highly recommend.

Must Be Nuts

Maria DanielsFusco

A Great Company to Support!

The peanut butters came quickly and well packaged!

Must Be Nuts

Maria DanielsFusco

We love it!

Delicious and lower in calories than regular peanut butter!

Cookies and Dream Nirvana

Josh Lumsdon

Best PB ever!

Taste amazing and kids love it too.

Crunchy Campfire Treat

★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

94%

(210)

5%

(12)

0%

(0)

0%

(1)

0%

(1)

K

Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors

Kristin Dunlop

Love this company… My peanut butter is delicious

Love this company… My peanut butter is delicious and I will definitely be ordering again!

T

Beehive Smunchy Butter

Tracy Stilson

I love it!! Can’t wait to try more of them

I love it!! Can’t wait to try more of them.

R

Sun-Kissed Swirl

Randall Moore

This one was great

This one was great. It was almost like a strawberry cobbler.

O

Golden Turtle Swirl

OhioMeiers

Insanely, eat-the-whole-jar delicious!

This stuff is insane! I bought a jar at the lodge in Zion earlier today. My 9 yr old is currently eating it by the spoonful - after I did the same. Obviously I’m already online planning my order. But seriously, this stuff is soooooo good!

K

Crunchy Campfire Treat

Katja Toro

I love it

I love it, the pb is really smooth, the rice crispies are still crunchy and not stale!

1 2 3