Nut Your Average Peanut Butter Bold flavors. Real mix-ins. Small-batch magic that makes every spoonful unforgettable.

Nut Your Average Dessert—Peanut Butter Like You’ve Never Had!

The perfect spread for dessert lovers, snackers, and gift givers.

Handcrafted Small-Batch Peanut Butter Magic—Spoon It, Spread It, Love It!

Shop flavors

New and Limited Time Flavors

View All
Cursor
Must Be Nuts
Golden Turtle Swirl
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Santa’s Sugar Cookie Surprise
$11.99
$13.99
$11.99
Must Be Nuts
Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors
$32.99
$32.99

THE CLASSICS

Churrolicious - Must Be Nuts
CHURROLICIOUS
Crunchy Campfire Treat - Must Be Nuts
CRUNCHY CAMPFIRE TREAT
Cookies and Dream Nirvana - Must Be Nuts
Cookies and Dream nirvana

OUR FAVORITES

View All
Must Be Nuts
Churrolicious
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Crunchy Campfire Treat
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Peanut Butter Overload
$14.99
$14.99
Must Be Nuts
Smunchy Butter
$6.99
$6.99
Must Be Nuts
Zero Dark Nutty
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Bravo Brew Butter
$13.99
$13.99

Let customers speak for us

from 171 reviews
This will keep me wide awake and it's so good.

Caffeine type PB!

Richard Smith
Bravo Brew Butter
Bravo Brew Butter
This flavor will keep me wide awake

This flavor will keep me wide awake.

Richard Smith
Zero Dark Nutty
Zero Dark Nutty
So yummy! One of my

So yummy! One of my favorites!

Krystal Bonde
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
A winning flavor combination

A winning flavor combination. I recommend eating this in a pantry alone so you don’t have to share

Spencer L
Bravo Brew Butter
Bravo Brew Butter
Eat this by the spoonful on a sad day…

Eat this by the spoonful on a sad day…. Or a happy one.

Spencer L
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
I haven’t tried a flavor I didn’t love

I haven’t tried a flavor I didn’t love. They are all so so good

Spencer L
Must Be Nuts
I don’t want to be dramatic

I don’t want to be dramatic, but this is life-changing.

Spencer L
Peanut Butter Overload
Peanut Butter Overload
Absolutely delicious!

Every flavor I purchased is absolutely delicious! Arrived much faster than anticipated too. Will definitely buy again. It makes a great gift!

Karen Georgeson
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Fast service

Fast service.

Bev Fry
Must Be Nuts
Great

Great flavor

Anonymous
Golden Turtle Swirl
Golden Turtle Swirl
Autumn in a jar!

Seasonal flavors have never been so good! Absolutely delicious! Can’t get enough of it!

Valerie
Honey Harvest Bliss
Honey Harvest Bliss
Perfect product for a gift!

Got this for my mother as a gift and she loved it!

Jake Parkinson
Brigham City Peach Paradise Cobbler
Brigham City Peach Paradise Cobbler
Love it!

I found them at the farmers market one day and tried their crunchy campfire treat! It was so good that I had to order more! Ended up getting more crunchy campfire treat, sun-kissed swirl, and zero dark nutty. All great flavors! My favorite is now the Sun-Kissed Swirl. Shipping was fast too!

Melanie Nerdin
Must Be Nuts
So yummy

I love peanut butter and these are delicious!!

Katie Miller
Churrolicious
Churrolicious
Yum!

Tried Smunchy Butter and loved it! The texture is perfectly smooth and rich without being overly oily. It has a slightly sweet, nutty flavor that makes it totally addictive—delicious on toast, fruit, or straight from the spoon. Clean ingredients, great packaging, and an all-around upgrade from standard nut butters. Highly recommend!

Patrick
Smunchy Butter
Smunchy Butter

#MUST.BENUTS ON INSTAGRAM

Home of the viral "Churrolicious" a butterscotch based peanut butter so good it makes grown men cry! 🥹
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts