Nut Your Average Peanut Butter Dessert in a Jar Loaded With Flavor

Nut Your Average Peanut Butter Dessert in a Jar Loaded With Flavor

Hand-Stirred in Small Batches • Real Mix-Ins • Bold Flavors

Hand-Stirred Small Batches • Real Mix-Ins • Bold Flavors

Shop The Flavors

New and Limited Time Flavors

View All
Cursor
Must Be Nuts
Midnight Brownie Crunch Peanut Butter
$14.99
$14.99
Must Be Nuts
Signature Peanut Butter Flight – 4 Bestselling Flavors
$32.99
$32.99

THE CLASSICS

Churrolicious - Must Be Nuts
CHURROLICIOUS
Crunchy Campfire Treat - Must Be Nuts
CRUNCHY CAMPFIRE TREAT
Cookies and Dream Nirvana - Must Be Nuts
Cookies and Dream nirvana

OUR FAVORITES

View All
Must Be Nuts
Churrolicious
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Crunchy Campfire Treat
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Peanut Butter Overload
$14.99
$14.99
Must Be Nuts
Smunchy Butter
$6.99
$6.99
Must Be Nuts
Zero Dark Nutty
$13.99
$13.99
Must Be Nuts
Bravo Brew Butter
$13.99
$13.99

Let customers speak for us

from 65 reviews
Peanut buttery Heavenly

Peanut buttery Heavenly delicious!!

Richard Smith
Peanut Butter Overload
Peanut Butter Overload
This is the best PB on the website

This is the best PB on the website. Highly recommend.

Richard Smith
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
A Great Company to Support!

The peanut butters came quickly and well packaged!

Maria DanielsFusco
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
We love it!

Delicious and lower in calories than regular peanut butter!

Maria DanielsFusco
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
Best PB ever!

Taste amazing and kids love it too.

Josh Lumsdon
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat
This will keep me wide awake and it's so good.

Caffeine type PB!

Richard Smith
Bravo Brew Butter
Bravo Brew Butter
Love it!

I found them at the farmers market one day and tried their crunchy campfire treat! It was so good that I had to order more! Ended up getting more crunchy campfire treat, sun-kissed swirl, and zero dark nutty. All great flavors! My favorite is now the Sun-Kissed Swirl. Shipping was fast too!

Melanie Nerdin
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
Delicious Peanutbutter !!!

This peanut butter was great ! What a taste combination ! A must have !

Nathan Harrison
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Magic In Every Spoonful

I love peanut butter. But this peanut butter is a fun experience of quality and goodness. I had heard that it was really good, but that is an understatement! It is by far the best peanut butter I have ever had. I highly recommend it!

Susan Kochik
Magically Nut-Licious
Magically Nut-Licious
Canine cookie crunch

My dog absolutely loves canine cookie crunch. She has a very sensitive stomach and cannot enjoy most treats. Her breed is Cavatzu. I was happy to find a special treat that my dog could enjoy. I would recommend canine cookie crunch for all dog breeds.

Susan Woods
Canine Cookie Crunch
Canine Cookie Crunch
Jump For JOY Peanut Butter

This peanut butter literally made me jump for joy with the first bite! It was so fresh and absolutely delicious! I will be ordering more, but trying a different flavor next time!! Great job Must be Nuts!!

April Brown
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
Just as good as you’re hoping for!

As most of you, I saw the viral TikTok and had to try. Churrolicious is amazing. I was worried it would be too butterscotchy, as I’m not the biggest butterscotch fan, but it wasn’t! Perfect balance with the other flavors. Can’t wait to try more!

Kim May
Churrolicious
Churrolicious
BEST Nut Butter I have EVER had!!!

I received 2 jars of CHURROLICIOUS today for my birthday from my work son. I CANNOT even describe how UNBELIEVABLY HARD it has been to ONLY eat 1/4 of the jar. I have never tasted ANYTHING like this, it is ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! Somehow I will have to hide this from the rest of my family because I am NOT sharing. I can't wait to try some of the other flavors, but the CHURROLICIOUS...YUMMY!!!

Cynthia B Mansour
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
I have my second shipment already coming!!

I have never loved peanut butter more!! Started with the Churrolicious & Oreo Nirvana and I'm obsessed. I am so looking forward to all the new flavors they will be coming out with!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!

Missy Smith
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
Best thing ever!

Man I gotten churrolicious ! Me and my son couldn't put the spoons down! What a delightful treat!

JOHANNA
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat

#MUST.BENUTS ON INSTAGRAM

Home of the viral "Churrolicious" a butterscotch based peanut butter so good it makes grown men cry! 🥹
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts

Let customers speak for us

from 65 reviews
Peanut buttery Heavenly

Peanut buttery Heavenly delicious!!

Richard Smith
Peanut Butter Overload
Peanut Butter Overload
This is the best PB on the website

This is the best PB on the website. Highly recommend.

Richard Smith
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
A Great Company to Support!

The peanut butters came quickly and well packaged!

Maria DanielsFusco
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
We love it!

Delicious and lower in calories than regular peanut butter!

Maria DanielsFusco
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
Cookies and Dream Nirvana
Best PB ever!

Taste amazing and kids love it too.

Josh Lumsdon
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat
This will keep me wide awake and it's so good.

Caffeine type PB!

Richard Smith
Bravo Brew Butter
Bravo Brew Butter
Love it!

I found them at the farmers market one day and tried their crunchy campfire treat! It was so good that I had to order more! Ended up getting more crunchy campfire treat, sun-kissed swirl, and zero dark nutty. All great flavors! My favorite is now the Sun-Kissed Swirl. Shipping was fast too!

Melanie Nerdin
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
Delicious Peanutbutter !!!

This peanut butter was great ! What a taste combination ! A must have !

Nathan Harrison
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Magic In Every Spoonful

I love peanut butter. But this peanut butter is a fun experience of quality and goodness. I had heard that it was really good, but that is an understatement! It is by far the best peanut butter I have ever had. I highly recommend it!

Susan Kochik
Magically Nut-Licious
Magically Nut-Licious
Canine cookie crunch

My dog absolutely loves canine cookie crunch. She has a very sensitive stomach and cannot enjoy most treats. Her breed is Cavatzu. I was happy to find a special treat that my dog could enjoy. I would recommend canine cookie crunch for all dog breeds.

Susan Woods
Canine Cookie Crunch
Canine Cookie Crunch
Jump For JOY Peanut Butter

This peanut butter literally made me jump for joy with the first bite! It was so fresh and absolutely delicious! I will be ordering more, but trying a different flavor next time!! Great job Must be Nuts!!

April Brown
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
Puppy Chow (Not for dogs ;)
Just as good as you’re hoping for!

As most of you, I saw the viral TikTok and had to try. Churrolicious is amazing. I was worried it would be too butterscotchy, as I’m not the biggest butterscotch fan, but it wasn’t! Perfect balance with the other flavors. Can’t wait to try more!

Kim May
Churrolicious
Churrolicious
BEST Nut Butter I have EVER had!!!

I received 2 jars of CHURROLICIOUS today for my birthday from my work son. I CANNOT even describe how UNBELIEVABLY HARD it has been to ONLY eat 1/4 of the jar. I have never tasted ANYTHING like this, it is ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! Somehow I will have to hide this from the rest of my family because I am NOT sharing. I can't wait to try some of the other flavors, but the CHURROLICIOUS...YUMMY!!!

Cynthia B Mansour
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
I have my second shipment already coming!!

I have never loved peanut butter more!! Started with the Churrolicious & Oreo Nirvana and I'm obsessed. I am so looking forward to all the new flavors they will be coming out with!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!

Missy Smith
Must Be Nuts
Must Be Nuts
Best thing ever!

Man I gotten churrolicious ! Me and my son couldn't put the spoons down! What a delightful treat!

JOHANNA
Crunchy Campfire Treat
Crunchy Campfire Treat